Saturday, May 10, 2014

Squad review

Counter to most peoples' expectations, this week's announcement of who has been released turned out to be surprisingly tame. Only three senior players are leaving, plus three who were on loan, with Jake Wright and James Constable both considering new deals. Where does that leave us?

The end of season release list is like Christmas in reverse. While Christmas is characterised by the accumulation of things, the release list represents a cleansing experience, an exfoliation of the woes of the season past. Both can feel equally rewarding.

The announcement of this year's released list couldn’t really have come too soon for us. There are a few fans who would have been happy to see the entire squad go. Many of those same people would have us sign pretty much any player from the Championship down that have been released by other clubs.

The shedding and signing of players isn’t that simple; players you want to say goodbye to can be under contract, others that we might want to retain may not want to stay. There are issues of squad balance, contract clauses and salary juggling; releasing great players to free up salary for a couple of good ones. And so on.

If he’s building from the back, then Gary Waddock may take a crumb of comfort from the fact he doesn’t have to worry about his goalkeepers. Ryan Clarke is nicely encased in a contract and Max Crocombe seems an able deputy for as long as he’s happy playing that role. The only question seems to be how long Crocombe will tolerate being in the shadows.

It’s in the back four where issues start to arise. The Chris Wilder (Ian Lenagan?) vision of a squad better equipped for the rigours of a League 2 season meant that Tom Newey and David Hunt were brought in along with Jonathan Meades. Meades, somewhat ironically given the requirement for robustness, has yet to feature because of injury. The Hunt/Newey combination has been a culture shock having got used to full-backs such as Damian Batt and Liam Davis storming the flanks.

The defensive qualities of Hunt and Newey helped provide a solid base from which counter attacks could be launched. This worked away from home, but at the Kassam, as teams sat back, they didn’t have the pace to stretch defences. A pathological reluctance to put in crosses meant that chances were at a premium leaving the strikers feeding off scraps. Despite Newey agreeing a new contract, the full-back positions have to be areas that Waddock will look to address.

In the middle of defence there is less to worry about; Raynes and Mullins had good, if injury interrupted, seasons, Jake Wright, by his standards, less so. There have been suggestions that Wright may even have been match fixing in the final game of the season against Northampton. This was based around a convoluted theory around Wilder wanting to sign him and it being in Wright’s interests to help keep them up. Whilst he looked shaky to say the least, it wasn’t the first time this season. Gary Waddock pointed to his injuries, which may be a factor. People forget how Wright developed under Chris Wilder, he had been drifting and it is only at Oxford did he begin to truly realise his talents. It seems a bit fanciful that Wright was match fixing, but I think he has once again lost his focus, if he can regain it then there are few better defenders in the league.

Our midfield is where major surgery is needed. There was a time when all we wanted was a team of Andy Whing’s, but Whing’s powers have been tested this season as injury largely wrecked him. Is that age catching up on him? Danny Rose was brought in as a creative dynamo, but rather like the Herbalife products he insists on pedalling, his signing gave some initial results before falling away badly. Wroe, similarly, started well before falling away and it’s not a surprise to see him heading back to Preston. I like Scott Davies a lot. He has a self-deprecating humour on Twitter – I particularly enjoy his publicly declared affection for his mum’s breakfasts - he seems like he’s the kind of player that managers like having around. That said, Waddock doesn’t have the luxury of spare wages to hand out to a court jester.

As a rule I don’t feel qualified to comment on the development squad players who have made their debuts this season, but all have looked comfortable when drafted into the first eleven showing signs that the new strategy of developing our own could be working.

You can split the attack into two; on the flanks there was Potter, Williams and Rigg. Potter’s presence tugs on the heart strings, but I think now is time to go our separate ways. Rigg too has failed to live up to his expectations and it wasn’t a surprise to see him released. Williams will head back to Fulham and I'm sure have a reasonable career worry the defences of the Championship.

Smalley was never destined to be retained. Waddock wouldn’t have survived the derision. All our strikers have been struggling; a lot to do with a lack of width and pace. Deane Smalley has been treated unfairly in my view, but 16 goals in three years was never going to suggest a new contract.

There may have been some temptation to retain Connolly, but that would surely have been a mistake. He clearly has class as a goal poacher, but he doesn’t have youth. If the financials can be sorted, then keeping Constable is good move. His goalscoring record hasn’t been great in recent years, but he’ll let no one down in a yellow shirt. With relations between club and fans in a brittle state, Constable could be the one to maintain the relationship.

The biggest enigma of them all is Dave Kitson. He has another year on his contract, but he seems to detest the game. A number of scenarios play through my head; the first is that Kitson is looking for some kind of self-definition that he can only find through football; to give up is to give into the unstoppable progress of age. It seems odd to continue to do something that he appears to hate so much. Related to that is the issue of depression, if his (alleged) book is right, then that might explain his uneven form. A final thought is that although despite him reportedly earning £10k a month from Portsmouth, he has money problems that means he simply needs to play for his salary. Personally, I'm not convinced about Kitson. If you think back to other ex-Premier League veterans we've signed in recent years - namely Gilchrist and Kitson, the second season has often been an injury ravaged disaster.

Waddock will surely focus his attentions on providing pace on the flanks and more firepower up front. But, with only three salaries released, can he do it?

1 comment:

Danny Steptoe said...

You mention only 3 released but then go on to mention 6 that have left us that will be replaced either by new season loans or perms

Ignoring the devs that is 6 out of a senior squad of 18 so a third to change.

I also expect the others u mention to find new clubs

Not a nag as I like your blogs